What is FIRPTA Is and Why Does It Matters in California Real Estate?

by The Ruiz Group

FIRPTA surfaces in California real estate transactions with enough regularity that buyers and sellers benefit from understanding it before it appears in their escrow paperwork. The acronym stands for the Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act, a federal law passed in 1980 to ensure that foreign nationals selling U.S. real property pay the taxes they owe on the gain. The mechanism is withholding: the buyer is required by law to withhold a portion of the sale price and remit it to the Internal Revenue Service on the seller's behalf. For transactions on the Monterey Peninsula, where international buyers and sellers are not uncommon, FIRPTA is a recurring consideration.

 

What FIRPTA Requires

When a foreign person sells real property located in the United States, the buyer is required to withhold 15 percent of the gross sales price and send it to the IRS within 20 days of closing. This is not 15 percent of the gain. It is 15 percent of the total contract price, regardless of what the seller paid for the property or what their actual taxable gain might be.

On a $2 million Peninsula sale, that withholding is $300,000 held by the IRS while the seller's tax liability is calculated and paid. The withheld amount is applied against the seller's actual tax obligation when they file their return. If the actual tax is less than the withholding, the seller receives a refund. If it is more, they owe the difference. The IRS holds the funds in the interim.

The withholding rate dropped from 10 percent to 15 percent in 2016 for transactions above $1 million. The rate structure as of the most recent guidance is: 15 percent for sales above $1 million, 10 percent for sales between $300,001 and $1 million where the buyer intends to use the property as a residence, and no withholding required for sales of $300,000 or less where the buyer will use the property as their primary residence. These thresholds and rates are subject to change; buyers and sellers should confirm current requirements with their escrow officer and tax advisor.

 

Who Is a Foreign Person Under FIRPTA

The definition matters because FIRPTA applies based on the seller's status as a foreign person, not the buyer's. A foreign person under FIRPTA includes non-resident aliens, foreign corporations, foreign partnerships, foreign trusts, and foreign estates. U.S. citizens and permanent residents, regardless of where they live, are not foreign persons for FIRPTA purposes.

The complexity arises because residency and citizenship are not the same thing. A U.S. citizen living abroad for 20 years is not subject to FIRPTA when selling a U.S. property. A foreign national who has lived in California for a decade on a visa may or may not be considered a U.S. resident for FIRPTA purposes, depending on how they qualify under the substantial presence test or whether they hold a green card. The determination is fact-specific and requires a tax advisor familiar with international tax rules.

Sellers who are not U.S. citizens and are unsure of their status under FIRPTA should consult a tax professional before listing their property. The determination affects how the transaction is structured and what documentation escrow will require.

 

FIRPTA places the legal obligation on the buyer, not the seller. If a buyer fails to withhold when required and the seller leaves the country, the IRS looks to the buyer for the tax. That is why escrow takes the question seriously.

 

The Buyer's Obligation

This is the detail that surprises most buyers: FIRPTA makes the buyer the withholding agent. If the seller is a foreign person and the buyer fails to withhold the required amount at closing, the IRS can hold the buyer liable for the tax, plus interest and penalties. The seller's departure from the country does not relieve the buyer of that obligation.

In practice, escrow handles FIRPTA withholding as part of the closing process. The escrow officer will ask both parties to complete certifications regarding the seller's status. The seller certifies whether they are a U.S. person. The buyer certifies their intended use of the property if they are relying on the residence exception. Escrow calculates the withholding, holds those funds at closing, and remits them to the IRS on the buyer's behalf. The buyer does not need to independently manage the withholding if a qualified escrow is handling the transaction, but the buyer should confirm that the escrow company has FIRPTA experience.

 

Exceptions to FIRPTA Withholding

There are several circumstances where FIRPTA withholding does not apply or is reduced, beyond the price thresholds noted above.

Seller certification of non-foreign status: The most common exception. If the seller certifies under penalty of perjury that they are not a foreign person, the buyer is not required to withhold. The certification must be in writing, signed by the seller, and retained by the buyer. Escrow typically provides this document. If the seller provides a false certification, the seller bears the tax liability, not the buyer, as long as the buyer did not have reason to know the certification was false.

Withholding certificate from the IRS: A foreign seller can apply to the IRS for a withholding certificate before or after closing. The certificate either reduces the withholding amount to reflect the actual tax owed on the gain, or eliminates it entirely in cases where no gain exists. The application process takes time, often 90 days or more, which affects timing if the seller wants to access proceeds at closing rather than waiting for the IRS to process the application. Sellers who know FIRPTA applies should initiate this process early.

Qualified substitute: In some transactions, a qualified substitute such as the escrow or title company can accept responsibility for withholding, substituting for the buyer. This arrangement requires specific written agreements and is handled at the escrow level.

 

California's Parallel Withholding Requirement

California has its own real property withholding requirement that operates alongside FIRPTA and applies to a broader set of sellers. Under California Revenue and Taxation Code Section 18662, the buyer in a California real estate transaction must withhold 3.33 percent of the gross sales price from any seller who is not a California resident, regardless of whether the seller is a U.S. citizen or foreign national.

The California withholding requirement has its own exemptions, including sales below $100,000, properties the seller certifies as their principal residence, and sellers who certify they will have no California tax liability on the transaction. Escrow officers in California are required to notify buyers of this obligation. As with FIRPTA, the funds are applied against the seller's actual California tax liability when they file.

In a transaction involving a foreign seller, both FIRPTA and California withholding may apply simultaneously, and the two calculations run independently. A well-structured escrow accounts for both.

 

How This Plays Out in a Transaction

From a practical standpoint, FIRPTA rarely derails a transaction if it is identified early and the right professionals are involved. The escrow officer collects the certifications, calculates the withholding if applicable, and handles remittance. Where it creates complications is when the question is not asked until late in the process or when the seller expects full proceeds at closing and has not planned for the withholding.

Foreign sellers who have not retained a U.S. tax advisor before listing often experience the first real friction at escrow when the withholding requirement becomes concrete. A seller who expected $1.7 million in net proceeds and learns that $255,000 will be withheld pending IRS processing has a problem if they have already committed those funds elsewhere. The withholding certificate process exists for exactly this situation, but it requires lead time.

The Ruiz Group coordinates with escrow and advises sellers to identify FIRPTA and California withholding considerations at the beginning of the listing process, not at the closing table. If you are a foreign national considering selling a Monterey Peninsula property, or a buyer concerned about your withholding obligations, contact The Ruiz Group before you are under contract.

 

Related reading: What Your Net Sheet Actually Tells You  ·  How to Read a Settlement Statement  ·  HELOCs Explained  ·  All About Jumbo Loans on the Monterey Peninsula

GET MORE INFORMATION

The Ruiz Group Real Estate

The Ruiz Group Real Estate

Database Manager

+1(831) 877-2057

Name
Phone*
Message